Clay Holmes of the New York Yankees currently shares the lead among all MLB players in saves, with nine to his credit, tying him with Robert Suarez of the San Diego Padres. Holmes has successfully converted saves in all but one of his opportunities this season, maintaining a perfect record of zero earned runs allowed and striking out 12 batters over 12 innings pitched.

Despite his stellar performance, which marks one of his best seasons yet in his seventh year in the majors, there’s speculation about his future with the Yankees. Tim Britton, in a projection for The Athletic, suggested that Holmes could be in line for a substantial four-year, $52 million contract extension from the Yankees if they decide to offer one.

However, according to Bob Klapsich, an MLB columnist for the Newark Star-Ledger, there seems to be no intention from the Yankees to pursue such an extension for Holmes.

“This much is certain: Holmes won’t be hearing from the Yankees before season’s end,” Klapsich wrote. “Very few players get early extensions; it’s club policy. Holmes shouldn’t take it personally.”

The New York Yankees Might Lose Reliever Clay Holmes After the Season

If Clay Holmes decides to explore free agency after what could be his career-best season, he is expected to attract significant interest from other teams. Sara Molnick, writing for Pinstripes Nation, highlighted the uncertainty surrounding the Yankees’ bullpen situation heading into the offseason if Holmes departs. Despite Holmes’ significant contributions to the team, the absence of contract discussions thus far suggests a potential separation when the offseason arrives.

Bob Klapisch’s insight aligns with the Yankees’ operating policy, as principal owner Hal Steinbrenner previously expressed a general skepticism toward contract extensions back in 2010. Steinbrenner indicated that he does not believe in offering contract extensions throughout the organization, regardless of the player’s status or contributions. This stance from ownership further suggests that Holmes’ tenure with the Yankees may indeed be coming to an end unless circumstances change.

While the Yankees did extend closer Aroldis Chapman in 2020, it appears that they might have regretted that decision as his performance declined thereafter. Bob Klapisch suggested that, at best, the Yankees might consider re-signing Clay Holmes to a short-term deal, but he expressed doubt about this possibility due to Holmes’ age.

Klapisch indicated that based on historical trends, Yankees GM Brian Cashman would likely advise Holmes to test his market value externally. Following this, Holmes would return with a contract figure, and then negotiations might commence for a short-term deal with the Yankees. However, Klapisch emphasized that this scenario would only unfold if Cashman and the Yankees’ analytics team believe that Holmes can sustain his current level of performance for another 2-3 seasons, particularly focusing on the effectiveness of his sinker pitch. This suggests that the Yankees’ decision regarding Holmes’s future will heavily hinge on their assessments of his long-term potential and value to the team.

Clay Holmes Says He’s Focused on Winning With the New York Yankees Before Free Agency

Clay Holmes remains focused on performing at an elite level with the Yankees, potentially compelling the team to seriously consider the implications of his departure. In recent remarks to Brendan Kuty of The Athletic, Holmes emphasized his commitment to his current role and team.

“I’ve developed strong relationships here with coaches and players, and I’m truly enjoying my time and where I’m at right now,” Holmes stated. “When the day comes that I’m no longer with the Yankees, I’ll evaluate my options. But for now, I’m here to contribute to winning as many games as possible.”

Holmes’s comments underscore his dedication to making a meaningful impact with the Yankees while leaving open the possibility of considering his future options if circumstances change. This stance reflects his professionalism and focus on maximizing his current opportunity within the organization.